With lots of speculation building up to yesterday’s Mariners’ manager Don Wakamatsu’s firing, it has made me think of the failure the Mariners have suffered since 2001. Buster Olney recently reported via Twitter “Heard this: There is a lot of unrest right now among some of the Mariners’ player development and scouting folks”. I believe the root of the problem is player development. The Mariners have been awful in the past decade and they have not used the draft to their favor.
After bringing up two of the greatest players to ever play baseball: Ken Griffey Jr. and Alex Rodriguez, the Mariners have had a rough time selecting players that will later contribute to their team. From 2000 to 2010 the Mariners have had eight 1st round draft picks and not one of them are on their MLB roster today.
Only three of those first round picks actually played at the top-level with the Mariners. Jeff Clement the team’s 2005 1st round pick only played 75 games for Seattle, Adam Jones the Mariners’ 2003 sandwich pick played 73 games and Brandon Morrow drafted in 2006 pitched in 131 games for Seattle.
Here are the Mariners’ top draft picks from 2000-2010:
2000: Sam Hays (4th Rd Pick) – Never pitched in the MLB.
2001: Michael Garciaparra (Supplemental 1st Rd, 36th Pick) – Has not played a game in the MLB, currently with the Houston Astros organization.
2002: John Mayberry Jr. (1st Rd, 28th Pick) – Did not sign with Seattle, went to Stanford and was drafted in 2005 by the Rangers. Made his MLB debut with the Phillies in 2009, currently on the Phillies roster.
2003: Adam Jones (Supplemental 1st Rd, 37th Pick) – Traded to the Orioles for Erik Bedard in 2008. In 2009 made the AL All-Star game and also won a Gold Glove.
2004: Matt Tuiasosopo (3rd Rd, 93rd Pick) – Has spent time as a utility infielder in 2009 and 2010 with the Mariners.
2005: Jeff Clement (1st Rd, 3rd Rd Pick) – Played 75 games for Seattle was traded to the Pirates for Jack WIlson and Ian Snell. Clement is playing regularly at 1B for Pittsburgh.
2006: Brandon Morrow (1st Rd, 5th Pick) – Pitched in 131 games for Seattle, was traded to the Blue Jays for Brandon League in December 2009. Recently has looked very strong, his last start he was one out from a no-hitter and ended the game with his first career shutout and 17 K’s.
2007: Phillipe Aumont (1st Rd, 11th Pick) – Aumont is yet to make his MLB debut. He was traded to Philadelphia for Cliff Lee.
2008: Joshua Fields (1st Rd, 20th Pick) – My favorite Mariners’ pick in this era. Standout closer at the University of Georgia and my choice for closer of the Future for Seattle.
2009: Dustin Ackley (1st Rd, 2nd Pick) – The All-American from North Carolina was drafted as a 1B/OF but has recently been trying to convert to 2B. A bright spot in the Mariners draft history, so far.
2009: Nick Franklin (1st Rd, 27th Pick) – Currently playing in A for Seattle, has struggled defensively but has good speed and is hitting .346 this season.
2010: Taijuan Walker (Supplemental 1st rd, 43rd Pick) – Signed with the Mariners in June and has pitched in two games thus far in the Mariners’ Arizona Rookie League.
As you can see many of these draft picks have been traded or have not succeeded in baseball. The last couple years have looked better as GM Jack Zduriencik has been in charge of the Mariners’ draft. Hopefully, some of the top prospects can live up their potential and help the big league club out soon. The Mariners definitely need the help.


